Nettime mailing list archives

<nettime> FW: Online games increasingly a place for protest, social acti
Michael Gurstein on Sun, 9 Feb 2003 19:48:51 +0100 (CET)

[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

<nettime> FW: Online games increasingly a place for protest, social activism

This isn't quite Hactivism, nor is it cassettes bringing down the Shah, but
the blurring of the lines between the virtual and the "in your face" seem to
be continuing apace...



-----Original Message-----
From: Michael Gurstein [mailto:mgurst {AT} vcn.bc.ca]
Sent: Saturday, February 08, 2003 9:31 AM
To: cpi-ua {AT} vancouvercommunity.net; community informatics; Nettime-L;
Ciresearchers Net
Subject: Online games increasingly a place for protest, social activism

Online games increasingly a place for protest, social activism

Canadian Press

Friday, February 07, 2003

NEW YORK (AP) - Gone are the days when playing video games online meant
simply playing a hand of poker or battling your buddies to the death in a
giant arena you couldn't control.

Many games are now all about role-playing, and some players aren't
participating to escape terrestrial life. They're getting on virtual
soapboxes and organizing all manner of protests in cyberspace. Gamers have
protested the impending war in Iraq, started newspapers, gathered charitable
donations - done myriad things they already do, or wish they could do, in
the real world.

The line between online gaming and the real world "is a lot thinner than
people give it credit for," said Raph Koster, creative director of the
Austin, Texas, office of Sony Entertainment.

At the new online community There.com, gamers can clothe their in-game
marionettes and socialize with others. Already, some players angry with the
U.S. policy on Iraq have organized a peace rally and clad their characters
with the peace symbol.

Not earth-shattering, to be sure, but exemplary of how thousands of people
are using online games to either project their real voices or speak up as
they might not in real life.

Players of EverQuest, the most popular online game in the United States with
about 85,000 playing at any time, held in-game candlelight vigils after the
Sept. 11 attacks and even created memorials within the game's universe.

Such games have become "online petri dishes" to show how far people will go
in wedding their real and virtual lives, said Amy Jo Kim, an online-games
designer involved with There.com.

People have been attacked in real life for killing other contestants playing
Lineage, the world's most popular online game with four million active
subscribers. And hundreds of players have gathered within the game to
protest software glitches.

The latest game to hit the market is the Sims Online, from Electronic Arts.
Players have control over a character and act out real-life fantasies.
They've built in-game restaurants, created several radio stations and even a

And they are not shy about complaining.

Freelance writer Tony Walsh didn't like a deal Electronic Arts made to
insert a McDonald's kiosk into the game, so he organized a protest.

Other gamers have no trouble co-opting games entirely.

To protest the possibility of war, Anne-Marie Schleiner designed a hack for
Counterstrike, a popular first-person shooter. With "Velvet-Strike," players
could display virtual posters with such messages as "Hostage of an Online
Fantasy" and "You are your most dangerous enemy."

It led to some confusion among gamers who didn't want reality creeping into
their fantasy world, Schleiner said.

"It was interesting, disturbing and entertaining to get so much negative
feedback from all different directions - some pure old-fashioned misogyny,"
she said.

Issues of how far gamers can push have yet to be fully tested. Like movies,
games are often based on brands, and designers aren't necessarily willing to
have their brands co-opted.

Likely to push those limits is the forthcoming Star Wars Galaxies, which
will put players inside the George Lucas popular universe. That creates a
problem, because the Star Wars world is one of the most cherished creations
in the history of fantasy fiction.

"Somebody saying something in the game and being witnessed by somebody else
can reflect not just on the game but on Lucasfilm and George Lucas," said
Koster, a lead designer for Galaxies, which is due in April. "If someone
started walking around in the San Diego Zoo screaming profanity or handing
out Nazi leaflets, the park would remove them from the premises. We need to
be able to do that also."

Should free-speech values extend to the online world? Will there be a future
lawsuit from someone who claims they were unlawfully barred for maligning
George Lucas?

Walsh, for one, believes gamers should have the very same freedoms in
cyberspace that they have in the physical world.

"Why shouldn't people protest?" he said. "Why shouldn't freedom of speech be
as alive in the Sims Online as it is the real world?"

Copyright  2003 The Canadian Press

#  distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission
#  <nettime> is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
#  collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
#  more info: majordomo {AT} bbs.thing.net and "info nettime-l" in the msg body
#  archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nettime {AT} bbs.thing.net