Nettime mailing list archives

<nettime> Paul Mason: Greece in chaos: will
Patrice Riemens on Thu, 2 Jul 2015 08:30:09 +0200 (CEST)

[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

<nettime> Paul Mason: Greece in chaos: will

original to:

Greece in chaos: will Syriza's last desperate gamble pay off?
Paul Mason
Monday 29 June 2015

The banks are closed, the bailout referendum is looming  -- and Europe's
only far-left government is struggling to hold on to its mass support. In
less than a week, it will either be triumphant or finished

If it all ends on Monday, with the Greeks voting for austerity in order to
keep the euro, the first far-left party to hold office in modern Europe
will be judged by its critics a failure.

By calling a referendum, Syriza has gambled that it can strengthen its
hand in negotiations with its lenders. But with no extension to its
bailout programme, and emergency funds from the European Central Bank
(ECB) on a knife-edge, the move has prompted this week's "bank holiday"
and the rationing of cash at ATMs.

With the opposition and business groups warning of economic catastrophe,
Syriza  -- which means "coalition of the radical left"  -- faces a nailbiting
week. What is at stake is whether this party of around 20,000 members can
hold the left half of Greek society together long enough to force the
lenders to negotiate  -- or whether it will crash and burn under the
pressure of popular anger and disillusion.

If they win, on the other hand, they will be seen as heroes by opponents
of austerity across Europe.

But win or lose, Syriza in office has been a work in progress, impossible
to read for people ignorant of Greece, let alone people who don't know
there are subcategories to moderate Marxism.

Greece under austerity has become frenetic. Athens right now is slick with
perspiration; every public space is charged with hormonal tension and
political disagreement  -- even the bakery where you buy your morning bread.
The politics are brutal. Last week, stick-wielding anarchist youths
attacked the HQ of the Antarsya  -- a far-left anti-capitalist party ?
because the latter had tried to make them pay to go into a music festival
when the anarchists thought it should be free.

I've seen, in the bohemian Exarchia district, a troupe of black-clad
15-year-olds distrupt a whole street full of similarly bohemian cafe-goers
on a Saturday night, using petrol bombs and flaming rubbish bins, simply
because "creating mayhem" is their doctrine.

Athens has become, in short, the stage for flamboyant acts of
self-dramatisation: sporadic riots, public kissing, street theatre and
ill-advised scooter techniques. It is, to use a phrase Huxley once used
about Shanghai, "life with the lid off", and for the same reasons: "so
much life, so carefully canalised, so rapidly and strongly flowing".

Antonis Vradis, a geographer at Durham University who has studied the
impact of repeated waves of unrest here since 2008, describes how the
youth networks have been preparing for this week's "rupture" with the ECB:
"They are creating structures you can't default on. Self-organised
clinics, the social centres you see all around you. Structures that will
help them survive."

I meet Vradis in Floral cafe on the corner of Exarchia Square. He points
out that the building  -- shabby as it is now  -- is a Bauhaus masterpiece.
More importantly, during the 1944 uprising against the British, "the
communists were snipers on the roof".

The young here live always with a portion of their brain operating in the
past. They don't need wall plaques. When they move through Exarchia, or
Syntagma, or up the side of parliament towards the mansion prime minister
Alexis Tsipras now occupies, they can "see" where the resistance fighters
died; where the students of 1974 stopped a tank.

It was the young people radicalised amid this landscape who pitched a tent
camp outside parliament in 2011. They organised a movement most foreign
journalists didn't see: local assemblies in small squares across the city
and its suburbs, where young mums, migrants and outraged pensioners could
have their say. The communists denounced them; the socialists sent riot
police to disperse them; Tsipras is said to have looked out of the window
of his office and delared: those are the people who will put us into

But Syriza is different. Syriza is a coalition whose colours are red for
socialism, green for ecology and purple for feminism. But it is primarily
red. It was born out of Eurocommunism  -- when the communist parties of the
west declared loyalty to parliamentary democracy instead of Moscow. Its
most influential activists are aged 50 and above: people who have read all
three volumes of Karl Marx's Capital, plus the Grundrisse, Theories of
Surplus Value and Friedrich Engels' Anti-Dühring. A lot of them are MPs
now, or special advisers: you'll find them in greying huddles in their old
haunts  -- the radical bars and cafes of Exarchia and Plaka.

How this generation of Greek leftwingers broke out of isolation is of more
than academic interest. They have managed  -- for the first time in modern
history  -- to form a government that defied the global finance system, and
to do so with flair.

Their strength was that they understood the significance of the youth
revolts of 2008 and 2011. Some pitched their own tents in Syntagma Square
and were tear-gassed out of it. But in the process, the party built
something more official and resilient.

Their weakness, it turns out, starts with Nicos Poulantzas. Poulantzas was
a Greek intellectual of the new left who famously clashed with Ed
Miliband's father, Ralph, in 1969 over the nature of the capitalist state.
Miliband said the state was "capitalist" because personally controlled by
the business elite. Poulantzas said the state was structurally capitalist
 -- independent of the will of individuals.

Poulantzas evolved a dual strategy for the Greek left in the 1970s: first,
to encircle the state with social movements, which were not to be
controlled by any party but allowed to become expressions of popular
democracy. And at the same time, to enter the state, democratise it and
use it to pursue social justice. Poulantzas killed himself in 1979, but
his ideas guided the precursor organisation to Syriza. Not many people
remember now, but the party's predecessor, Synaspismos, joined a
short-lived coalition government with the conservatives in 1988, and a
national government thereafter.

In the runup to its election victory, Syriza got a chance to execute the
Poulantzas strategy of the march through the state: it won the Euro
elections and the vital prefecture of Attica, where its candidate was
protest veteran Rena Dourou. Then it won state power  -- but that has turned
out differently.

When Tsipras took over the Maximos Mansion, the PM's residence, the
outgoing government removed all computers and all soap. There is soap now,
and computers, though no Wi-Fi for security reasons. Tsipras rules from
one side of a marble hall; the other side is the cabinet room. In the
basement are secure meeting rooms and offices. At the weekend, you will
often find somebody's children crayoning on the floor. The ceremonial
guards, in their white tunics, sip freddo-cappuccino on a narrow terrace,
alongside press photographers and armed bodyguards.

In power, Syriza has discovered the unguessed secret of the Greek state.
Without oligarchs, it is inefficient. So thoroughly did the old parties
use patronage to run the operation that they barely needed a civil
service, or the shock absorbers provided by independent regulators and
quangos normal in a state such as Britain. I have seen ministers
confronted with ridiculously detailed operational decisions, such as the
appointment of a new boss for the state TV channel, which in Britain would
be delegated to a regulator, but in Greece fell to minister of state Nikos
Pappas. Finance minister Yanis Varoufakis routinely handles his own press:
though he has press officers drawn from Syriza, the actual press operation
of the Greek state is barely engaged.

Yannis Dragasakis, Greece's deputy prime minister, was in many ways the
embodiment of Syriza's long-term dreams. His team of advisers included
those most attuned to the "horizontalist" agenda emerging out of the
networked social movements; people whose main desire was to nurture the
70-plus small-scale economic experiments they had promoted: local
currencies, Wi-Fi networks in the mountains, producer co-ops.

But Dragasakis was given "operations": to operate the government, to
firefight the banking system, to sort out the state energy company. Those
who expected his department to unleash a wave of entrepreneurship and
experimental projects have had to wait.

Probably the most challenging job in Greek journalism right now is to work
for Avgi, Syriza's newspaper. It is a daily, with professional graphic
design, but suffers because nobody can decide whether it is meant to carry
the party line or to be a voice for the mass base, and therefore a pain in
Tsipras's butt. When I meet editor-in-chief Giorgos Kiritsis, he is
surrounded, almost symbolically, by fading newsprint and old posters. He
chain-smokes and pulls up a Facebook page on which someone has posted a
50,000 drachma note with Kiritsis's face on.

Nobody knows what 50,000 drachmas will be worth if Greece defaults on its
debts, but Kiritsis and his colleagues have for months been exposed to the
basic dilemma of Syriza. It is a coalition  -- including the hard,
pro-Moscow left who want that drachma note to become real; a centre around
Tsipras who wanted to try to shrug off austerity within the euro; and
former social democrats who want, at all costs, to do a deal with the

It was not until 4 June that Tsipras became convinced that his original
strategy  -- to go on paying the lenders while negotiating the fine detail
of an accord that never seemed to come  -- was fruitless. It was at this
point that the forces in Syriza realigned leftwards and the strategy of
the troika (the ECB, IMF and European Commission)  -- which had always been
to split Syriza, forcing Tsipras and his own moderates into a coalition
government with the centre parties  -- was in tatters.

The ultimate question for Syriza, with the banks closed and the referendum
due, is: can it now function as a movement? It has ridden to power on the
back of social movements but, unlike Podemos in Spain or Sinn Féin in
Ireland, has never really been a mass movement itself.

In the middle-class suburb of Chalandri in northern Athens, the mayor,
Simos Roussos, has to organise the referendum and simultaneously keep the
machinery of government going. Roussos was elected on a joint slate
between Syriza and Antarsya party. He tells me the council's gas supplier
refused a delivery on Monday  -- not on the grounds that he wouldn't get
paid, but on the grounds that he didn't like what Syriza is doing.

We meet at a council-run clinic where, after midday, the official GPs and
psychiatrists give way to a team of volunteers. It is run this way because
the austerity under the previous govenrment means they can't staff the
clinic with paid employees. The volunteers include doctors, psychologists
and qualified pharmacists, but I find them engaged in the menial task of
hand-sorting donated medicines. They note the sell-by dates, count the
pills and sort them. This is Syriza's mass base  -- but it is not Syriza.

Syriza was always a party before it was a movement. The early polls taken
since the referendum was called indicate it still has mass support. The
unanswered question is whether it can hold the leftwing half of Greek
society together amid this week of chaos.

Nineta, one of the volunteers at the clinic, tells me people are
frightened, but that she is totally behind what Syriza has done. The
antidote to fear is solidarity, she says. But nobody is sure how much
solidarity can survive if the banks stay closed.


#  distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission
#  <nettime>  is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
#  collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
#  more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l
#  archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nettime {AT} kein.org