www.nettime.org
Nettime mailing list archives

<nettime> Damir Pilic: Red Revival: The Fall and Rise of Karl Marx
Patrice Riemens on Sat, 30 Apr 2016 10:13:55 +0200 (CEST)


[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

<nettime> Damir Pilic: Red Revival: The Fall and Rise of Karl Marx


Original to:
http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/red-revival-the-fall-and-rise-of-karl-marx-10-16-2015


Red Revival: The Fall and Rise of Karl Marx

Meet the academics whose devotion to Marxism cost them their jobs in the 
1990s — and the thinkers driving Marx back up the political agenda 
across Europe today.

By Damir Pilic in Split, Zagreb, Athens and London


"The gap that has been left by the departure of this mighty spirit will 
soon enough make itself felt." (Friedrich Engels at Marx's funeral, 
Highgate Cemetery, London, March 17, 1883)



Zvonko Sundov, a doctor of philosophy, got his last pay cheque 24 years 
ago. Still, the 63-year-old insists on paying for both coffees. The 
years he spent as probably the most educated homeless person in Croatia 
have not broken him.

"Reality is a trap for every thinker," he says.

In 1991, Sundov was fired from the Zagreb School of Electrical 
Engineering. He won court cases against his dismissal in both Zagreb and 
Strasbourg but he has never returned to the classroom — because his job 
no longer exists. He taught Marxism.

In socialist Yugoslavia, Marxism was a compulsory subject in all 
secondary schools and colleges. Then came the fall of the Berlin Wall in 
1989 and the collapse of communism, when, in his famous essay The End of 
History, American political scientist Francis Fukuyama proclaimed the 
eternal victory of liberal democracy and capitalism.

Hundreds of Marxism teachers and professors were left without jobs. 
During the great changeover, they were despised as couriers of 
totalitarianism who had no place in a democratic society.

But now Europe’s political landscape is changing: leftist movements are 
gaining strength due to the international economic crisis. At the 
beginning of 2015, Europe got its first government of radical leftists 
since The End of History, with the victory of Greece's Syriza, a 
political movement that grew out of the Communist Party. In Spain, 
Podemos, a movement close to Syriza, has come from nowhere to establish 
itself as a third force in national politics.

Germany’s Die Linke party last year took power in the state of Thuringia 
on a democratic socialist platform, with a lead candidate who campaigned 
with a big red bust of Karl Marx. In Britain, the new Labour party 
leader Jeremy Corbyn has said Marx is a "fascinating figure... from whom 
we can learn a great deal".

It seems the Marxist values which cost Sundov and others their jobs are 
returning to the European stage. Even Fukuyama has been talking about 
the problems of inequality and the dominance of finance in the 
capitalist system.

Against this backdrop, I wanted to explore what happened to those 
professors of Marxism who lost their jobs — and how they and today's 
European Marxists view the apparent revival of socialism. Is Syriza a 
continuation of their interrupted dreams? Is Greek Prime Minister and 
Syriza leader Alexis Tsipras their democratic Lenin for the 21st 
century? What might now be plucked from Marx’s beard to build Europe's 
future?

"Marxism's time is yet to come," claims Sundov, as we sip coffee in a 
Zagreb cafe in May this year. He then goes on to quote another socialist 
icon: "Rosa Luxemburg said 'socialism or barbarism', and today we have 
barbarism. Syriza and Podemos are a human act of rebellion. Besides 
Marxism, capitalism doesn't have a serious enemy.

Capitalists know: if anyone can destroy them, it’s the Marxists. This is 
why Syriza is facing so many problems in negotiations [with the European 
Union]."

After he was fired, Sundov admits, he struggled to find his feet. His 
students greeted him in the street, but the teachers from the staffroom, 
now former friends, avoided him. The professor also got divorced. His 
ex-wife threw him out of their apartment in his shorts and slippers.

"I slept on a bench at the railway station and, in the winter, in 
abandoned train carriages alongside tramps. I had lived a normal life 
and now I was suddenly out in the street. And the books were back at the 
apartment. And I was left without any friends."

But Sundov was not without philosophical companions. He cites 
Heraclitus's phrase that one man is worth ten thousand if he is 
great."And I had two," he explains. "Hegel and Marx."

Finally, in 1996 the gods of good fate smiled on the exhausted Marxist. 
He met his future wife at a lawyer’s office. He was suing his old 
employer and she had probate proceedings. The crucial factor: the lawyer 
was late.

“She invited me to a café for some tea - and I didn’t have a penny in my 
pocket. She also had some sandwiches and she offered me one. I hadn’t 
eaten anything for three, four days, but I was embarrassed to take it 
since I couldn’t even pay for the tea. She talked me into taking the 
sandwich anyway. And we've been living together for 20 years now. She 
saved me."

Sundov will soon publish a book about Hegel. It will be the fourth book 
he has written since he started living with the woman who invited him 
for tea.


A Marxist 'hotbed'

Mira Ljubic Lorger, who has a doctorate in sociology, is another Marxist 
academic for whom the collapse of communism had dramatic personal 
consequences.

Until 1990 she worked at the Social Sciences Research Centre in Split, a 
university institute which was, in the eyes of Croatia's new 
anti-communist government, a hotbed of Marxism.

The centre was accused of religious persecution and swiftly shut down — 
even though it worked together with priests, Lorger says.

"Ironically, my project was entitled 'A Dialogue between Christians and 
the Left'. It was stopped halfway through because they left me without 
funds. So much for a dialogue between Christians and the Left," she 
says.

To survive, she had to turn to an old hobby: astrology. The Zagreb 
weekly Nacional asked her to write horoscopes for them.

"And my son tells me: 'I'd like to have some meat for once.' Because at 
that time we only ate dough and pasta."

She asked Nacional to let her write under a pseudonym, but they wanted a 
doctor of sociology so their horoscopes would have credibility.

“So I called all my friends and begged them not to buy Nacional. I was 
embarrassed," she tells me in her Split apartment. "It was either that 
or death by starvation as a respectable dissident. And I couldn’t opt 
for the latter because of my two children."

Now retired, she closely follows developments in Greece. She believes 
the victory of Syriza is the most important social and political event 
in Europe of the past 20 years.

"Syriza will probably collapse, but the fact that leftist governments 
have started winning in Europe is a sign of a new era. I see this as my 
own, private victory, as if I had a third child."


In 1990 philosopher Dusko Cizmic Marovic was working at Split's Marxist 
Centre, a communist party-backed political and scientific institute that 
existed in larger cities of socialist Yugoslavia.

After the centre was dissolved, as a former journalist and editor of 
student newspapers, he wanted to live off his writing.

"Southern Europe could be the 'second wing' in the international process 
that would challenge the domination of the free market and capitalism"  
-philosopher Lino Veljak

But, he recalls, war broke out between Croatia and Serbia and he found 
his writing was "far too gentle" for the political climate. "So I became 
a fisherman," he says.

Marovic borrowed money, took out a mortgage on his wife’s apartment and 
bought a trawler. But the capitalist adventure failed and in 1996 he 
lost the apartment because he couldn’t pay back the debt. He also lost 
his wife to cancer.

"I lost the apartment, the trawler and my job. I was left with two 
children, I had to rent a place. I would throw away any bills. I 
connected the power myself without paying for it. I lived off 
non-existent money," recalls Marovic, who returned to journalism after a 
left-liberal coalition replaced nationalists in government in 2000.

He is now the editor of the university monthly Universitas.
A doctor of philosophy as a homeless person, a doctor of sociology as a 
horoscope writer, a journalist as a fisherman: these are the fates of 
Croatian Marxists following The End of History.


Communist 'fraud'

In contrast to their colleagues in schools and research institutes, 
university professors of Marxism in Croatia fared somewhat better. These 
were philosophers and sociologists who could also teach other subjects.

Lino Veljak taught Marxism and ontology at Zagreb University until 1990, 
then only ontology. He remembers when some colleagues "changed their 
flag" and adopted a new nationalist agenda.

"The most hard-core Marxists became anti-communists," he says. "And 
moderate Marxists continued being moderate Marxists."

The best-known Croatian convert from Marxism to nationalism is 
78-year-old Zdravko Tomac, now an intellectual icon of the Croatian 
Right, whose books are bursting with anti-communism.

But Tomac once worked with Edvard Kardelj, the creator of the Yugoslav 
model of "socialist self-management" — under which workers ran state 
enterprises — and the closest associate of long-time Yugoslav leader 
Josip Broz Tito.

Tomac confesses to me that Marx was a "discovery" for him in his youth — 
especially the idea that one should not just interpret the world but 
also try to change it.

"This is why I decided to write books about self-management," he says. 
"I had an opportunity to work with Kardelj, to listen to visions of a 
new world."
Tomac now believes the biggest misconception of Marxism is that a 
violent overthrow of capitalism could lead to a better society.

"There's also another incorrect assumption – that the collective is more 
important than the individual, that the Party determines what is good 
and what is bad," he claims. "This abolishes not just freedom of 
expression but also freedom of thought."

Tomac adds that he has seen "the power of the communist idea" and 
understands why, in his words, many decent people accepted "this fraud".

"Because communism encompasses some humane ideas, ideas that every 
democratic person can relate to. The thesis that, instead of financial 
capital, those who generate income should also be the ones in charge of 
management is seductive. I know many people who believed this idea was 
worth sacrificing their life for."


Stalin's ghost

In every interview, the ghost of Stalin hovered over the audio recorder. 
All my Marxist interviewees felt the need to distance themselves from 
him. They see Syriza as the first step towards democratic socialism in 
Europe, one that would be clearly different from the 20th century 
totalitarian version.

"Alongside Latin America, Southern Europe could be the 'second wing' in 
the international process that would challenge the domination of the 
free market and capitalism," Veljak declares.

My interviewees concluded that the revival of Karl Marx came about 
because European social democracy turned right, leaving a space on the 
left. When the international economic crisis broke out, a new Marxist 
generation occupied this space.

A part of this generation assembled in Zagreb in May: Syriza political 
secretariat member Yiannis Bournous, prominent Podemos member Antonio 
Sanchez and the head of Slovenia's United Left parliamentary group Luka 
Mesec.

All three took part in a panel debate entitled 'The New International'. 
Mesec and Sanchez, both 27, were babies in 1989. Only 35-year-old 
Bournous remembers The End of History.

"I remember clearly the demolition of the Berlin Wall, the taking down 
of the USSR flag over the Kremlin and the big break-up of the Greek 
Communist Party (KKE)," he tells me after the debate, adding that his 
parents were KKE members.

These young men did not study Marxism in school and yet all openly 
acknowledge the strong influence of Marxism on their thinking.
"Yes, we are using the Marxist apparatus to analyse capitalism and to 
devise alternatives," Mesec confirms.

"Syriza connects Marxist movements with the centre," adds Bournous.
"Marxism is Podemos’s companion, in combination with the experiences of 
the Latin American Left," says Sanchez.

"It's possible to address people in a Marxist way even in the 21st 
century" -sociologist Toni Prug


One prominent supporter of Podemos is Teresa Forcades, a 49-year-old nun 
who holds doctorates in public health and theology and lives in the Sant 
Benet de Montserrat monastery near Barcelona.

When talking about the Left, she uses the pronoun "we". She inherited 
her leftist orientation from her parents, fierce opponents of Franco’s 
Fascist dictatorship.

"I have always been a left-winger, and the new thing in my life was 
religion, which I discovered at the age of 15," Forcades says during a 
visit to Croatia in May.
Even though she insists that she isn't a Marxist, because "Marxism 
promotes atheism", Forcades appreciates Marx.

"When you read The Communist Manifesto, you see faith in the progress of 
humanity," she stresses. "Capitalism was not brought by God but by 
people. And God cannot be responsible for history, but people: I agree 
with Marx on this," Forcades says. We did not create the world, she 
adds, but the world is ours to complete.



'The Future Is Unwritten'

Syriza shares at least some of her vision. In Athens, at the party 
headquarters in Eleftherias Square, youth prevails. Except for a 
cheerful café on the first floor, the offices are modest, almost 
ascetic.

"Yes, I'm a Marxist," 40-year-old Syriza political secretariat member 
Andreas Karitzis tells me in a sparse room devoid of computers. There is 
only a motorcycle helmet on an empty shelf.

"As a left-wing party, we firmly believe that the logic of profit and 
capitalism is destroying the planet and creating widespread poverty," 
says Karitzis.

"But we don't believe that we can switch to socialism directly from 
capitalism, as the Communist Party believes. Yes, we want a society 
different from the capitalist one, but we believe that it needs to be 
built from the bottom up and not by a political decision from the top."

An attempt at such a society already exists in Athens. The Exarchia 
district is sometimes called the heart of European resistance to 
capitalism.

This is the home of anarchists, the hard-core wing of the Greek Left. 
Police rarely go there as they are greeted with Molotov cocktails.

There are no capitalist brands here and the walls are covered in 
anti-capitalist graffiti. "The Future Is Unwritten" reads one slogan.

"You can’t pay with cards here, we only accept cash," 26-year-old chef 
Alexander Papadopoulos tells me in his restaurant. "It’s the same in the 
whole district. This is our form of resistance to capitalism."

The concrete park in the centre of the Exarchia District is decorated 
with banners against capitalism. Young people discuss society and 
politics, while dogs hang around at their feet. Many men have beards.

A modern, urban version of Plato’s Academy: more aggressive than the 
archetype, but without slaves. Immigrants are welcome here.
Chef Alexander Papadopoulos in his restaurant in Exarchia. Photo: Damir 
Pilic

"Exarchia is organised in a way that we're all equal: me, you, Tsipras," 
says Papadopoulos. "Maybe it's impossible for the whole society to be 
organised in this way, but it's possible in Exarchia."

I spend two June evenings at protests in Syntagma Square in central 
Athens: on Wednesday, demonstrators are in favour of Syriza, on Thursday 
they are against.

There are more young people on Wednesday. They do not know that Syriza 
will capitulate to the European Union on austerity a few weeks later.



On Friday, in London, I see the same slogan I saw two days earlier in 
Syntagma Square — "End Austerity Now". This time, on a poster for a 
protest, the next day at noon, outside the Bank of England in the City.

The following day, tens of thousands of people throng the financial 
district. "We've come to save the welfare state," Angie, a teacher, 
tells me. "Public education and health are going to hell. If we don’t 
rebel, there’ll be nothing left."

Surrounded by many anti-capitalist banners, I am not sure whether I am 
in Syntagma Square, in the Exarchia concrete park or in the epicentre of 
global capitalism: there are embittered people and, in the background, 
the spirit of Karl Marx.

But then London is Marx’s city: "the father of scientific socialism" 
spent the last 34 years of his life here.

This is where The Communist Manifesto was printed in 1848, in the 
offices of a communist organisation at 46 Liverpool Street.

This is where Das Kapital was written. The spiritual centre of original 
Marxism was not Moscow but London.



Lenin on a laptop

In the evening, as we stroll through hedonistic Soho, Croatian 
sociologist Toni Prug tells me that living in London made him a Marxist.

"I grew up in Yugoslavia under communism but politics never interested 
me," says Prug, who is 43. "Then I came to London [in 1996] and worked 
at the reception of the Alexandra Hotel in Paddington for a year, 10 
hours a day for three pounds per hour.

There were two Bulgarian women working with me there 14 hours a day for 
two pounds per hour: they cried and sent the money back home. That was 
rock bottom. That’s when I bought a laptop and started reading Marx and 
Lenin. If you don’t become a Marxist after such an experience, there’s 
something wrong with you."

Prug then worked as a computer programmer for 10 years, paying his way 
through sociology studies. He got his PhD from Queen Mary University of 
London with a thesis entitled Egalitarian Production and Distribution of 
Goods and Wealth. The purpose of egalitarian production is not profit, 
he explains, but fair distribution.

He says this is Marx's most important contribution and cites the example 
of socially-owned apartments in the former Yugoslavia.

"If you have another child, you get another room. And free public health 
and education, of course. And yet the Westerners think the state is 
evil. Capitalism doesn’t have any scientific theories on socially owned 
apartments because there is no profit involved."

According to Prug, "the heart of Marx’s work" has never been so 
relevant, but there was too much improvisation and misinterpretation of 
Marx in the past.

"However, Marxism is gradually entering European parliaments. It’s 
already in, through Syriza," he notes. "This proves that it's possible 
to address people in a Marxist way even in the 21st century."

Whether Syriza can turn Marxist ideas into reality remains to be seen. 
After a brief first term dominated by a failed attempt to face down the 
EU on austerity, it won re-election in September.

We wrap up the story of Karl Marx’s resurrection at Highgate Cemetery in 
north London. Marx is the most popular 'resident' here: his picture is 
on the cemetery’s official poster. Many visitors stop by his monument, 
often to take selfies.



Inscribed atop a grey granite plinth supporting a large bust of Marx is 
the final cry from The Communist Manifesto: "Workers Of All Lands — 
Unite". At the bottom of the plinth, I read: "The philosophers have only 
interpreted the world in various ways – the point, however, is to change 
it."

A sentence that all Yugoslavs had to know to pass Marxism class in 
school. A thought that enchanted millions in their youth, even 
Marxist-turned-nationalist Zdravko Tomac, and inspires others to this 
day. Including a boy at the grave wearing a Che Guevara T-shirt, with 
his left arm in a red plaster cast decorated with a hammer and sickle.

"My son talked me into coming here, he has become a Marxist,” laughs the 
boy’s mother, Julie Goodman-Church. "They were learning about the Cold 
War in school and had to research what came before. And then one day he 
came to me and said: 'Mum, Karl Marx is a great guy.'"

The boy’s name is Ben, he is 14. One of the youngest European Marxists. 
Has he read any of Marx’s books?

"The Communist Manifesto," he says proudly.

Ben was born in the 21st century, Marx died in the 19th. It seems that 
Friedrich Engels was not wrong when he ended his funeral speech for his 
best friend with the words: "His name will endure through the ages, and 
so also will his work!"

At the end of this tour of 'Marxist Europe', as I bid farewell at 
Highgate Cemetery to the man whose thoughts I had to learn by heart in 
school, I remember what Macedonia-based philosopher Ferid Muhic told me 
at the beginning of my research. Muhic is a proud Marxist but he said:

"People are not beings of great ideals, and Marxists cannot understand 
that. Epicurus said: 'A few friends in a garden, a jug of wine and a bit 
of goat cheese – that is the meaning of life.' I think Epicurus was more 
right than Marx. That’s the tragedy of Marxist minds."


.............

  This article was produced as part of the Balkan Fellowship for 
Journalistic Excellence, supported by the ERSTE Foundation and Open 
Society Foundations, in cooperation with the Balkan Investigative 
Reporting Network.



#  distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission
#  <nettime>  is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
#  collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
#  more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l
#  archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nettime {AT} kein.org
#   {AT} nettime_bot tweets mail w/ sender unless #ANON is in Subject: