Nettime mailing list archives

<nettime> The Data Prevention Manifesto
birds on Fri, 11 Nov 2016 15:42:45 +0100 (CET)

[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

<nettime> The Data Prevention Manifesto

The Data Prevention Manifesto

...by the Plumbing Birds

The privacy discourse sputtered out of steam. This has lead to the
current stalemate: we know we're observed, traced and tracked, but
pretend it's not happening or nothing to fret about. The question
is not when the repressed will return but how? Hackers have been
proclaiming that privacy has been dead for decades, that everything
can and will be captured, stored and analyzed. And they were right.
So, what's to be done?

What's the best way to protect one's self if not prevent to transmit
data in the first place? Effectual hindrance of data coming into
being. How to convene a collective dimension of "social networking"
without being aggregated in huge data silos extraneous to us, yet
profiting on us? 
How can we reclaim autonomy in our everyday life,
Knowing that all sorts of sensors, bots and algorithms are active?
How can these technologies ever be decommissioned? Are we perhaps
waiting for a Great Showdown, a WorldWar, a millennial cyber attack
that brings down the entire infrastructure, a bad solar flare or an
electronic magnetic pulse knocks out the power grid and erase all hard
drives? Or are we about to fall asleep and be numbed forever, having
accepted that everything we do, think and desire, can and will be
stored, and can be used against us?

We need to de-codify contestation in order to multiply the lines
of flight outside of calculated settings. We need to ask the hard
questions, too. Adblockers, filters, firewalls, close-reading of
terms & conditions and online protests against the collection and
reselling of private data merely mitigate the problems that are at
stake. More to the point, what logic does data protection participate
in? Is it, effectively, the same logic it aims to cloak and hide from?
Why do we think life can be informationalized? What desire feeds the
notion that big data can be transformed into a knowable, manipulated,
gamed, anticipated, preempted, capitalized and controlled life? Are we
hedging and feeding Unicorns or Frankensteins?

We're not talking about the weather. Let's move from protection to
the design of an anti-serum, or rather a deep serum that not merely
responds. Our credo is: do not feed the platforms. We're proposing
creative sabotage, concrete forms of prevention that undermine the
'big data' regime on all levels, from the molar to the molecular.
Let's take concrete steps towards an overall data reduction. We will
no longer feed the data-hungry Minority Report machines that are
programmed to identify emerging erratic behavior.

Data prevention is a direct response to top-down 'smart' city
technologies. We aim to uphold a preventive-strike. The 'smart'
discourse is only trying to cover up the fact that these are spying

Prevention sounds innocent, but make no mistake, it is not. In many
cases prevention itself is already seen as a crime. Do we only talk
about preventing events from happening, or are we also generating new
scenarios? Data prevention is part of a longer history, we recall
the opposition of native Indian Americans to having pictures of
themselves taken, the punks in the streets of London punching fashion
photographers for commodifying their looks.

Ted Hughes once spoke of the grin hat was trying out faces. Well,
that's real. In our case it is fear attempting to become integral.
Fear is trying out all human capabilities. Fear can trick us into
living a nudged and predictable life. This has come to pass as
generation after generation corrupt, spineless, greedy people have
been in the drivers seat. We cannot call it leadership. These people,
let's say Bilderberg, Fortune 500 and MBA globally have facilitated
anything ‘easy', outsourcing anything ‘hard' to places that could
be exploited. So now there is no more place to exploit. Hence the
fight for the internal space, the very notion of what it means to
be human. We live in a world where people can not be exploited and
enslaved, yet for the shame some would feel of having been deceived
for so long about what use is made of their data, hara kiri would be
their only option. Most people cannot wake up as there is no longer
a self to wake up to, just consumed refractions of a zombified and
spectacularised self.

We intend to launch a campaign to gather ideas about designing
products and services that do not gather data. To us is important to
say farewell to the premise that data is the oil of the 21st century.
All data can and will be financialized, this is the inevitable step
programmed deep inside most data architectures themselves. We want to
disassociate ourselves from the dark side of financialization of data.

We also question the 'mining' aspect of the data mining metaphor of
resource extraction. Digging up resources is a devastating environment
crime that ruins our planet, from tar sand mines to coal pits and
digging for cobalt. Mining comes with a high price. Mind the metaphors
you use.

We need to get rid of the idea that data traces are things that
we ‘leave behind' in some careless way. It not only legitimates
the drag net, but it diverts attention from the rather aggressive
techniques that inspect our browsers, networks, and devices. We
therefore need to reshape the possibilities of data production.

This also means we need to stop drawing parallels between computation
machines and the human brain, between data and grey matter.

If it is true that the machine only works when all the relevant people
are convinced, we need to tell other tales. Convictions are not
innocent; they are about re-making worlds. You invest in it.

Let's stop celebrating the invisible, de-activation, retreat. Let's
quit the visualization of data centers, data points, data pattern,
data collection and recognition algorithms. We're tired of being
smeared with how Big Data might smell, feel, look or sound. We do no
longer want to play into the game or change its rules.

Data prevention is not a strike, it is only perceived as sabotage by
the apparatus needing to be fed by data. We do not believe in safe
ways to deal with ‘big data' collected to monitor, and control,
populations. What we prevent here is a conditioned, ultimately
boring life that limits itself. Let's get rid of the guilt to do
the forbidden and then feel the heavy presence of Big Brother, the
all-seeing God that will remember every tiny move or bad thought. Let
see it as consensual sex without consequences: data prevention creates
space for pleasure and possibilities, it is not done to save precious
space on our hard disks. Being in the space for possibility is
breaking free from the dual pole of production (of data) and paranoia
(for the same dynamic).

Let us err. Collectively.

We need to materially engage with the enigmatic, the flawed, the
partial, the impure, the surprise, the transgressive, the Black Swan.

These days prevention is an offensive strategy that questions hidden
power relations. It's not just passive hiding but taking action.
Let's prevent this political tech design initiative from ending up in
the offline Romanticism section. All actions, gestures, thoughts and
movement can and will be captured and caught in the data trap. This
can make us depressed, but this fate can also be turned upside down.
There was and always will be an abundance of data. Let's break free
from the prospect to lock ourselves up in voluntary monasteries and
other tribe-like inward looking social structures. There is no need to
save data, let alone recycle them.

Data prevention makes a fresh start and leaves behind a tiring
discourse. The idea is no longer merely to filter, install
blockers and build walls, protecting ultimately instable and open
architectures. We create new design principles. Data prevention goes
in the offensive. We're tired having to protect ourselves.

Join in this new design movement! Make people aware of what happens,
and switch off what needs to.

Engineers are taking us to real-time, thinking that it is an empty
space. But we live there in dreamtime. We were ever caught by surprise
in the plains. The rain dance went limp. Authorities caught us
fishing, labelled aboriginals and slaughtered us filled our minds with
cluttering noise and meaningless chatter chatter chatter. Counting on
this we would lose the open line. This time, this time we occupy that
space with our tools and dreams as we live and we eat your tools and

We, the Platform Plumbers, want you to tell us about your favorite
things. Describe them any way you want. We record the richness of your
emotions and feelings for your favourite things. We are getting used
to doing with less. After all the sensors just measure light, motion,
temperature, magnetic fields, gravity, humidity, moisture, vibration,
pressure, electrical fields, sound, stretch, glucose level, oxygen
level, or osmolality, anything else? Probably a few things, but you
can do much better. Don't you forget that. Practice. Start now and
join us in shaping the Dionysian design genre.

Do not be afraid: we will work with you and your structures. We do
need to appreciate the ethos of bureaucracy. All your assets, as you
call them, belong to us to none no one. You my friend who is evil keep
yourself evil still, the four horsemen and the jumper are hurrying

So it is up to us to make things find the hard road again. This is not
a mass movement. It can only be done with those who are on the path
already. If you are, read on. If you are not, don't feel bad, there
are plenty things left to do and who knows you may break through one

We will see you when you see us. You'll see us when we see you.

The Platform Plumbers

Platform of the Plumbing Bird

Platform Plumbers
we know what hides behind walls
and how to drill all the necessary holes
for good and bad
to fix, to change and maintain the pipes
to flood, disrupt, deny the waters.
Responsibility is not control
Awareness is a mercyfull weapon for the wise.
Is better to be aware today (brothers and sisters)
and awake at night as we must
standing for responsible data pregnancy,
and fair data under a fairer sky/

Plato holds data (doxa) accountable of confusion and all wrong opinions
and Episteme he calls the field of the wise, that knows how to mark the 
We don't need faith into some theoretical dogma
We stay on the side of the platform
-on wich opinions falls as droplets-
and we sum up -upon us- the ability to collet these waters
knowing what to share, to store, to let go.
Because we are willing to use the source wisely
in the time of the drought
for humans, animals and woods alike
Because we share the point of view
of the whole ecosystemical bunch

Hold up to this notion of belonging
hold up to your refined data politeness
over their agendas of hidden data policies
and know what you can then well teach
to hold on before what you can only preach well

They say: money
money -without us- has no economical trust
we can better put trust into money that we bake ourselve up
and get on the path uphill
to "other ideas" that are good. Better.
Virtualised economies
fueled up by remote notions of debt
are obsolete by design,
and going to be worthless

Citizens, conspire to unfullfill the one way exploitation
to grow ecosystems of polite automatic conversations between pairs
instead of feeding motorised pushers of unwanted sleeping pills and 
snake oil
and allow these drops to be clean water for all of the living souls on 
this plain

while we learn, and sleep and love, outside,
the un-attended trap of tracked down, data-silos stored,
overvalued, obviousness works against us
we have no agency on the data, and we should
and the data is not the truth but her shadow, we know
to be used at will by self hypnotised puppetteers
to create fictions that does not compile into histories;
advertising for unwanted goods;
bed time stories for the lust of self loving politicians;
serving the one ideals of "the one percent"
We should have agency on data
because every shadow is a shadow of a body
hit by the light under the sun
we shall be close to these droplets and their sources
and the melting ice in spring
and say no thanks when we must
and please no when we feel is our right/

We shall meet again (brothers and sisters)
on the verges of this gorgeous green land
once a desertified mud-bowl
each of us able to speek the language of choice
to amuse the friends and make the childrens laugh
ad we will be called the platform plumbers
the designers of the garden's grid
the layers of the pipes, of filters, of the recycling ponds
the choosers of the right seeds to keep
the letter-go of wild grasses and bees
-because no design holds the whole-
we will be remembered as the observers of the waves
the happy carvers of algorithmic stones
that needed to grow into no pyramidal graves

Let the policies of the politeness-poets speek tonight
in, above and below the grid

#  distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission
#  <nettime>  is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
#  collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
#  more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l
#  archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nettime {AT} kein.org
#   {AT} nettime_bot tweets mail w/ sender unless #ANON is in Subject: