André Rebentisch on Wed, 30 Jan 2019 02:40:07 +0100 (CET)
|
[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]
Re: <nettime> No evidence of digital wrong-doing...
|
- To: bhcontinentaldrift@gmail.com, nettime-l@mail.kein.org
- Subject: Re: <nettime> No evidence of digital wrong-doing...
- From: "André Rebentisch" <tabesin@gmail.com>
- Date: Wed, 30 Jan 2019 02:35:35 +0100
- Autocrypt: addr=ar@opentechsummit.net; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= mQINBFRJDxwBEACdn9/OFwFMexlb5FkFuPrdgf4ecfNIMZ7zFDffVOhuT7gst1j/FXaBOLHp LURBhDDu8ETWUDSqmObzR0fcTtOEoyBIyYnRS/7gQ4a3vtdYn9ioBQCNcKc36CEgAPNfHOWF HXpjR84+Vu66qxgB27nZBph+x2hdXMfwQpRbHdm4Vq/f+nWiLd8v/QPCaR9BeqHguG7wNhZS Puv82pKZhl8f1d0xJZ58i/Slxm+wUQhH24t0dDxdm571kFk97PdUzxP/G2cVkNpCg9nW2xXr ZFOKytgVN6s7GGUa1HSfCUmeaAHBbPk04PclNJVxj7KD0mmG99nbGFdjyY1QLt9g2R8kXt2s UlB6XHdfIAyINBsQxT/d2pyKv9/OMjpKaSA87W5+ushwtCBOViO1Zl4YeauBiw++Y+Riy+Ff hfRJzjvHaDzSO9ozAtgrzKGQCRm+bejdjfuJTuVN/c6zMY3jrBztjonAlA9ZLXzRKG/HPqin rsSafVg+lm+CsaETicGo4TFrrLqIADfnsTsSgk+mihsSkTOx8RdXykKx7Smnbdq2CMCRxMos rLVo1e/VkjUwIwXbGcl049L2W4Exb2u51g4VYyvbar8LY2RrLow9XbEVyi++NzMbtVXzNdSf uksOgPf88AMkJ40B7tbPdFBSkqAzPbgtNjcddBJ05qxvAzkNIQARAQABtClBbmRyw6kgUmVi ZW50aXNjaCA8YXJAb3BlbnRlY2hzdW1taXQubmV0PokCPgQTAQIAKAUCV9WuZQIbIwUJCWYB gAYLCQgHAwIGFQgCCQoLBBYCAwECHgECF4AACgkQFeebZgOY/HtP4g/+K7M8LcWeMr/Gc5li QZnxD1m7WjvsABsfoMw6SPHQmtkzAxFR7t1dX3aETnsr42yiSdn5wafJW2cDu66cRsJCVY2h jAFUNvOOSuHPniXvpGX33DlF2ynUyF7Cb/T/ZXFEOI5kXOuCodjPZiuDD8fqHcjXkwqYRE5u qM+NJ83bqs7o57Xw6PW39GdDx4lzjbe4BxFzudEtpFocXdSwTk5+vPbaPC67f0Or4Do60M5V ZU5/RyoNa5G81gR08l9LO7sUxwdOgtKJnLlYL5h1mmYESTLLIqpxAKfp9FYYddt3stCbdHZA /aDwOurl7Ns1w4ptpJjXExuF1NMRaEPVl0scp/+XbDC5PuUo47qBzcnQ/Guog4ZUs5bHRgdI xFAZmGH7k6ucoEPjSw+/IBJvIahAsklPLAS4f3O//oQXayLkr3GL78mHqTN3iY/QmCEIw5Vr v9ulmhp1rB+eA4i5NPA8541QdIzFwDMyxKBp+nIbgX1SBxz+BqEiC+YQgwVDyh3s85xVo5vw CygFiEpvASvnYqMgYfWmkpwPIE3T/iSq6oQj0tnHSb5PWRgPImhNtgcVcgWiFK65tfnBk0l1 Oa0fKUWkM22aLhjxN3iJN8EvN1gXBudJdtDki6tViaGvTer1vzBEtldh2rhGW/xEel1FJKjM ZzHdP5IlUBZpi90vHiO5Ag0EVEkPHAEQANrNrtHzQw2c5v7C3m+PGiEZem/+Xx36xNhFlGjW OAcTSA1WVCT7Spn0ADiCv+rlntnDCH7qp7hPmB6CGg+cvFH4dUeXVGRuHgkGv6P9GWEhJd7W RIlOu51mGnXaElkps4wAbvhln+Brk+fbWf4Vy2qiXJxsbDEdes9qdgtnE0SfS2cyB6HcFNkp 384ML8DynwAbQf43qottT0pDmpTXX4r6Gk59pE6qGad1/WGi001kFNFNW+CInDTjif6wkzYc Unqc+pDcAsyl52CO7a++IpKzvjPRi5wQysJdayCtpehvqzbF95NVg4ELVd5UIjJCNsMJEaoD N4+6t+m7AhhtV4yKlqHlBM37j0hBFIgCvFTc4ftUw9yllDOcFilasNcheSMR0IrAH0EjSp3W v0uDrTIB8/GiVUUIpkAN31IMMPCmkwBW5jhnAXAcWs0kqpTnQuCQeMEjf97PaRSQIC62fwEw thHPEyuUohdYoWuSF76SYFWqWyCvhTfe54DgIm51nAZAaIw8gmkBzMGkgXrEr+vrvD+IEWLW /u39+jcgyfoPFk6/I44Gg59quXeoJd+u/5XZC7/l/80libxo7fYb78efGzjb0mLESdVUIFev imQ92xbayoGtDVFfoYhqaP55nAz7bEzZ+3gkBNuxLov+RLqFBGG8QDTvJipGtBuoZmifABEB AAGJAiUEGAECAA8FAlRJDxwCGwwFCQlmAYAACgkQFeebZgOY/HteeQ/6AxQlhfYeZRi1JADj PACGaS1N3SRqfSBHpj4Ys9u3QozBr6u5n4WNBQljw46hL7WnvRiUE5V/ibaYe8r2Z+kzF1q5 67W2i3sh2ospqO66UrI8uZ7ddEkykqpYO5fkRt558Ct3b8Nqu6xndTbTJ3pDMyQbPs51V+DZ G1nVeosZ5BFsBIjFZTyDRXjvg4HOxn5axF7FJlikBsqWuF1BCxr+VJw2QvsG/Q9mdtl15mG1 jRvNmEyHSROunJtupAl/vo1eQjBJZ8XVFSP/lqHUlSLy77XsYfmzg4sjC9RbAvpnH9Mw2OZN gkFjbatlf4gtjZCeExTHCQ+DjfOANzswJ5tUcZB1b5RiJE/2hb5zRRkM2Fk16tC4Vwl15ncP nrrGsrGvM4uH/sOWpFJi1v14aiOB0uVfR5ZMb8rTq+jMDnpycESPG+tWJvwv6zKJTrS/acz8 h0JXgveqX9UG0n4gh0BGsh5kR00PfHp+Vr1mD/HkRKAC9lv7nS/IGFVlrq3sOnmXBGmUB8dp Zdua/PjxTNAhi/neQKpHR9JfnzVza8ATbQ5LKtPiuHdPhyJhD4peGCqN/f22HKXO6Dpp08kO Rah2YecgcEoBwZGt+QhlR734dd7LDUAb8lqvNnPaneQKsD1vkeBzcOwQvUgsvtnHSs1jzRiH 7kkvC1Lt1iIGZgKg5C0=
- Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmail.com; s=20161025; h=from:reply-to:to:references:openpgp:autocrypt:subject:message-id :date:user-agent:mime-version:in-reply-to:content-language :content-transfer-encoding; bh=R7xCXqrzPjgIB7PxgsMXRNcAxlt83pXDQh3BMKadq+Y=; b=D7NfBXBWIi98B7GoI7gp4P9SN/xqcpCsYpKg2MZczJG6/B8yjLsRido+QW72nTfQS5 vrXd2HCG+7ThfcQUoPfgvqJls2kkZwbWZgS8I8WpKMVj5IecL65L6u3LrHNx8hSC6JJo Qzjpd+EIYh3zpsIZtRcdDNCANyAmbNClh1UG6UZjmJKIR5JPdhmSqm8OT3LtqbIvYXsv vPvkS7zmYLGPJrOUtRGOJkZUfrPpkeWAtjn1Z5GNm2M8Y2xu4yVDBtlp2231UDiKsWgm VpjM9EBLYkDuU8B4o0yQ6QVnqatC9mzMi0CRSclJobADflWS21Ylk2MHxm7wdjRUTsue x8dg==
- In-reply-to: <CANuiTgwd2o7-oYbqGhsXhpLB7Eht46LeFPp0xo_5jHwSLfv3bQ@mail.gmail.com>
- Openpgp: preference=signencrypt
- References: <E0EE7DF3-6574-4969-88E5-7290476E6FC7@new-tactical-research.co.uk> <8c1bf7f2-2fed-7c32-af6e-6bd1f2e99e0f@lowtech.org> <8a6fb463-ad26-77a7-ed29-d8673dc07268@gmail.com> <c8da022787d6253efd60373f7d5c2e5f@xs4all.nl> <91E490C8-2FE1-4AB2-A149-546168B2AE75@new-tactical-research.co.uk> <20190128124635.GA25407@lo.psyced.org> <19913da3-fbfa-7e63-d413-49b061ac2149@openflows.com> <111620AF-C786-4C40-95A9-1B70F80C0FD4@panix.com> <CANuiTgwd2o7-oYbqGhsXhpLB7Eht46LeFPp0xo_5jHwSLfv3bQ@mail.gmail.com>
- Reply-to: ar@opentechsummit.net
- User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:60.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/60.4.0
Whenever you have a deliberative assembly the outcome it predefined by
the process. A sausage machine may grant you a right to select meat but
the outcome is always sausage, regardless of your selection. Or you get
something like a social democratic committee paper, where each sentence
has to be vague and is agreed upon by all, or has been previously agreed
upon, thus the outcome is mostly baseless or manipulative, e.g. by
shifting a principle on one level (all persons should be equal/free) to
another level (all net traffic should be equal/all men should be free to
shoot their machine guns) etc.
Deliberative committees are paper interventions against rocks that are
ultimately serving the ones governing the process. Indeed, your process,
dear representative tokens, produced a nice agenda plan, but we are the
officials and we pick what we want. A deliberative assembly has never
the power to command the execution of their consented plan but still
expects all participants to take ownership of the mediocre result.
What works however well is disjunct scenario planning, e.g. with four
scenarios. Then we usually get four "radical" plans. None of them would
be executed in a pure form either but we avoid the consent without power
and keep the tension, we develop the disjunct ideas to a more
sophisticated level.
Just as an example:
- Hard Brexit on WTO rules. Ordered custom Brexit. Brexit reversal.
Norway/EFTA.
- Hardborder, Soft border, Irish Union, NI stays in the EU.
Wouldn't it be great to have detailed plans for all scenarios?
Am 28.01.19 um 21:53 schrieb Brian Holmes:
> So the question is: What kinds of social forms can be used to re-mediate
> the formation of public opinion? In the recent past we tried forums, not
> just online ones, but big online/offline experiments like the global
> social forum process. These actually gave tremendous results for the
> relatively small number of people who plugged into them, and that's why
> we're still able to carry on significant discussions here and in many
> other places. But all those micropolitical fora have been too small and
> too disconnected from decision-making power. In the present,
> nation-states and supra-national formations are threatened with
> political breakdown, leaving no replacement strategies except
> authoritarianism or Hobbesian civil war. Televised, streaming and
> web-archived Citizens Assemblies sound like a great option under these
> circumstances.
>
> OK, the keep-hope-alive department is signing off for the moment,
>
> Brian
>
>
>
> # distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission
> # <nettime> is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
> # collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
> # more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l
> # archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nettime@kein.org
> # @nettime_bot tweets mail w/ sender unless #ANON is in Subject:
>
--
André Rebentisch Dipl. Kfm. & M.A.
Reuterstr. 32 12047 Berlin Germany
Fon: +49 30 44 35 78 96 Fax: +49 72 15 09 66 37 69
Cell: +49 16 36 99 23 09 Tw: @agonarch
eMail: ar@opentechsummit.net Web: http://www.opentechsummit.net
GPG: 0398FC7B // D9DF D3EB 2E79 9B93 2F31 07EE 15E7 9B66 0398 FC7B
Tax ID (Germany): 81 240 539 731
# distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission
# <nettime> is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
# collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
# more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l
# archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nettime@kein.org
# @nettime_bot tweets mail w/ sender unless #ANON is in Subject: