www.nettime.org
Nettime mailing list archives

[Nettime-nl] Putin’s Imaginative Plot: from tyrant to martyr
Tjebbe van Tijen via Chello on Tue, 28 Feb 2012 13:28:37 +0100 (CET)


[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

[Nettime-nl] Putin’s Imaginative Plot: from tyrant to martyr


Putinâs Imaginative Plot: from tyrant to martyr

February 28, 2012 by Tjebbe van Tijen

The illustrated version with web links can be found at:

http://limpingmessenger.wordpress.com/2012/02/28/putins-imaginative-plot-from-tyrant-to-martyr/

----------------------------

ââPUTIN ASSASSINATION PLOT DENOUNCED AS RUSSIAN ELECTION SPECTACLEââ The Guardian 27th February 2012. (1)

There are multiple meanings to this news, but they all end up with the same conclusion in favour of strong man Putin running once more for president: a win win situation.

There is first of all a historical analogy and referenceâ. which fits in with Putinâs role of the new Czar.

An attempt at the life of Putin to take place â as news sources say â in Moscow the day after his election, on his usual ride to work through the capital. Supposedly a bomb attack, which  in the Russian mind traces back to the assassination of Russian Czar Alexandre II in 18881, March the first, by conspirators of the âNarodnikiâ followers  of the Narodnaya Volya (Peoplesâs Will) movement. An act to show to the poor and subjugated majority class of the peasants that the Czar  was not an omnipotent supernatural being, that his life could be taken and their position of powerless could be changed.

If the plot against Putin was real, the Chechen conspirators would have revenged the suppression of their revolt against the Moscow reign of Chechen people. An answer to the Second Chechen War, a merciless clamp down strongly supported by Vladimir Putin. An act of tyrannicide by the Chechens as a symbol, a start to liberate themselves from Putinâs yoke. For many Russians such an act of revenge would prove the need of a strong figure like Putin to protect their homeland from the rebellion of insurgent regions, religions and nationalities. Putin as the man to stand up against those threatening the unity of what is left over of the great Russian empire. Something constantly expressed in the core message of Putinâs rhetoric: the protection of the Russian fatherland.


[tableau of the face of Putin with a greek sculpture of two tyrant killers merged and the text "ÐÑÐÐÐÑÐÐÐÐÑÑ ÑÐÐÐ ÐÐÐÐÑÐÐÐÐÐÐ (use your imagination"]

If the plot was â completely or even half â staged (by provocative methods), Putinâs secret service entourage would have used Putinâs widely expressed negative appraisal to create an event that can be imagined to be true. The proposed story line of a newly elected president killed straight after the day he has been elected fires the imagination and changes â even if it did not actually happen â  his position. We know, that when it would have had happened in real, all forging of election results would be overshadowed by such a drama and soon be forgotten. Putinâs role would have changed from âa tyrantâ into âa martyr for democracyâ. Real or fake, it hardly matters. Putinâs Plot has enough verisimilitude to fire peopleâs imagination and he will profit from that.

[same tableau negative version; of the face of Putin with a greek sculpture of two tyrant killers merged and the text "ÐÑÐÐÐÑÐÐÐÐÑÑ ÑÐÐÐ ÐÐÐÐÑÐÐÐÐÐÐ (use your imagination"]

Tyrannicide is the assassination of a tyrant for the common good. A tyrant in classical Greek history was someone who had taken power in a âpolisâ by illegal or unconvential means. In the year 514  Aristogeiton (the bearded one) and Harmodius assassinated one of the two sons of the tyrant of  Athens, Peisistratus. Their deed is said to have helped the establishment of Athenian democracy. A bronze statue has been made of the two âtyrannicidesâ by Antenor and placed to their honour in the Agora, the public meeting space close to the townâs assembly. We all do know that âAthenian democracyâ was something meant only for the local male population, excluding women and Athenian residents originating from other poli and not to forget: slaves. 

ââââ
(1) A choice of three news source renderings of the alleged plot agains Putin

THE GUARDIAN, Miriam Elder in Moscow, February 27., 2012: âThis is part of a clear election campaign,â said Yevgeniya Chirikova, a leader of the protest movement that has brought tens of thousands of people onto the streets of Moscow calling on Putin to quit. âItâs to bring attention to Vladimir Putin, and to develop this idea that thereâs a threat everywhere. Itâs a spectacle.â Putinâs press secretary described such statements as âblasphemousâ. (â) State-run Channel One television reported that two men arrested by Russian and Ukrainian special forces in the Ukrainian port of Odessa earlier this year had been dispatched to kill Putin by Chechen rebel Doku Umarov, the leader of Russiaâs separatist Islamist movement. (â) Channel One said it received information about the assassination attempt 10 days ago but did not explain why it did not release the news sooner. (â) Putinâs critics allege that a series of apartment block bombings on the eve of his first election in 2000 were orchestrated by the Kremlin to boost the then unknown politicianâs popularity, rather than by Chechen rebels, as claimed. A similar assassination attempt on Putin was allegedly foiled on the day of Russiaâs last presidential election in March 2008.â

CBS ATLANTA, Vladimir Isachenkov Associated Press, February 27. 2012: âThe Ukrainian Security Service said earlier this month it had detained a man sought by Russian authorities on charges of terrorism and two of his accomplices in Odessa on Feb. 4, but said nothing at the time about linked them to an anti-Putin plot. (â) Channel One said the source for its information was Russiaâs Federal Security Service, the main KGB successor agency dealing with domestic security. The agency refused to comment. (â) A Chechen rebel website, KavkazCenter, shrugged off the report about the assassination plot as âelection propaganda nonsense.â The website noted that the explosion in Odessa was initially reported to be a gas leak and the men were said to be preparing explosives for a contract hit on a local businessman. (â) The nationalist party leader, Vladimir Zhirinovsky, said the assassination plot was invented by political spin doctors and designed to appeal to âpoorly educated old ladiesâ and housewives, the news agency reported.â

KAVKAZ CENTER web site (a channel used regularly by Chechen opposition), February 27., 2012: Putin said that the victory over the Chechen rebels is one of the major achievements of his reign. Putin has counted the victory over Chechen rebels as one of the key achievements of his rule, and the report about the alleged plot is likely to further boost support â, ÐÐ reports from Moscow. An influential French daily, Le Monde, writes: âFor Frederick Longuet-Marx, chairman of the conference at Caen University, an expert on Islam and national identity in the Caucasus, âit was clearly a pre-election manipulationâ. âVladimir Putin just want to inflate a bit his pre-election rating and play on the fear of the Chechens. Indeed, during his 12 years of rule in Russia, Vladimir Putin has created an image of a strongman over his fierce struggle with Chechen terrorists. âThanks to the assassinations of 1999, which were clearly the work of Russian secret services, the public opinion was prepared to resume the war against Chechnyaâ, recalled Frederick Longuet-Marx. Today, the prime minister is opposed by the growing mass of people, and he is forced to use once again the bogey of Chechen terrorism, which helped him so well in the past. However, other people seem to doubt. () âOsmayev is completely unknown in the ranks of the Chechen movement, and the nameâ Pyazninâ sounds absolutely non-Kazakhâ, explains Frederick Longuet-Marx. He has also doubts about the very existence of the alleged terrorist organization. () âFor an Islamic terrorist, it makes no sense to take refuge in Ukraine. The laws there are the same as in Russiaâ. () Another major French newspaper Le Figaro quotes an independent Moscow sociologist Dmitry Oreshkin on KGB anti-putinist radio Ekho Moskvy: () âThis is a sign that people from the FSB are trying to use the tools to mobilize public opinion in an old way: âWe are surrounded by the enemies. There is only one strong, intelligent and courageous leader, whom they are trying to eliminateâ.



Tjebbe van Tijen
Imaginary Museum Projects
Dramatizing Historical Information
http://imaginarymuseum.org
web-blog: The Limping Messenger
http://limpingmessenger.wordpress.com/




______________________________________________________
* Verspreid via nettime-nl. Commercieel gebruik niet
* toegestaan zonder toestemming. <nettime-nl> is een
* open en ongemodereerde mailinglist over net-kritiek.
* Meer info, archief & anderstalige edities:
* http://www.nettime.org/.
* Contact: Menno Grootveld (rabotnik {AT} xs4all.nl).